Cheddar-Topped Beef Cottage Pie

• Potato topping
• 2 ½ lb yukon gold potatoes, peeled and cut into 2-inch chunks
• 3 tbsp unsalted butter
  Swaps for unsalted butter

  Instead of butter

  • Salted butter: The same amount, with about ¼ tsp less salt per stick (½ cup) elsewhere in the recipe. Nothing noticeable once you cut the salt.
  • Plant-based butter sticks: The same amount. The closest swap.
  • Refined coconut oil: The same amount: solid when the butter is soft or cold, melted when it is melted. It is all fat, so bakes are a bit more tender and rich, with no butter flavor.

  All 4 swaps for butter

  Cooking for an allergy? Check every label.

• ½ cup whole milk, warmed
  Swaps for whole milk

  Instead of milk

  • Unsweetened soy milk: The same amount. The closest plant milk for baking: its protein helps things brown and set.
  • Unsweetened oat milk: The same amount. Creamy and mild with a hint of sweetness.
  • Unsweetened almond milk: The same amount. Thinner and less rich, so cakes are a little paler and drier.

  All 5 swaps for milk

  Cooking for an allergy? Check every label.

• 1 cup cheddar cheese, shredded, divided ≈ 113 g
  Swaps for cheddar cheese

  Instead of cheddar

  • Colby or Colby Jack: The same amount. Milder and softer, and melts very smoothly.
  • Monterey Jack: The same amount. Mild and buttery, one of the best melting cheeses.
  • Gouda or Gruyère: The same amount. Nuttier and richer; melts beautifully.

  All 4 swaps for cheddar

• 1 tsp kosher salt
  Swaps for kosher salt

  Instead of salt

  • Table salt or fine sea salt: About half as much as Diamond Crystal kosher, about ¾ as much as Morton kosher. The same saltiness when measured this way.
  • Salt by weight: 1 tsp is about 6 grams of table salt, 5 grams of Morton kosher, 3 grams of Diamond Crystal kosher. The most reliable way to swap, especially in baking and brines.

  More for salt

• Filling
• 1 tbsp vegetable oil
  Swaps for vegetable oil

  Instead of vegetable oil

  • Another neutral oil: The same amount. No difference.
  • Melted butter: The same amount. Richer, buttery flavor; cakes are a little less moist and firmer once cool.
  • Light olive oil: The same amount. "Light" olive oil tastes mild.

  All 4 swaps for vegetable oil

• 1 onion, diced
  Swaps for onion

  Instead of onion

  • Another onion: The same amount. Yellow is the all-rounder; white is sharper and crisper; red is milder raw and adds color; sweet onions are mildest.
  • Shallots: The same amount, chopped. Milder and sweeter, with a hint of garlic.
  • Leeks: About 1½ times as much, white and light green parts. Milder and softer when cooked.

  All 4 swaps for onion

• 1 ½ lb ground beef, 85% lean
  Swaps for ground beef

  Instead of ground beef

  • Ground turkey or chicken: The same weight. Leaner and milder; burgers and meatballs are a bit drier.
  • Ground pork: The same weight. Richer and slightly sweet.
  • Plant-based ground: The same weight. Close in tacos and sauces; cooks faster.

  All 4 swaps for ground beef

  Cook ground beef and pork to 160°F (71°C) and ground turkey or chicken to 165°F (74°C).

• 3 cloves garlic, minced
  Swaps for garlic

  Instead of garlic

  • Garlic powder: ⅛ tsp for each clove. Mellower and sweeter, with no bite.
  • Jarred minced garlic: ½ tsp for each clove. Milder and slightly sour from the preserving liquid.

  More for garlic

• 2 tbsp tomato paste
  Swaps for tomato paste

  Instead of tomato paste

  • Tomato sauce or passata: 3 tbsp for each 1 tbsp paste. Lighter, fresher tomato flavor.
  • Ketchup: The same amount. Sweeter and vinegary; fine for a tablespoon or two.

  More for tomato paste

• 1 tbsp cornstarch
  Swaps for cornstarch

  Instead of cornstarch

  • All-purpose flour: 2 tbsp flour for each 1 tbsp cornstarch. Sauces turn cloudy instead of glossy and a bit heavier.
  • Arrowroot: The same amount. Very clear and glossy; can turn slimy in dairy sauces.
  • Potato starch: The same amount. Thickens fast with a clear gloss; don't boil it long.

  All 4 swaps for cornstarch

  Cooking for an allergy? Check every label.

• 1 cup beef broth
  Swaps for beef broth

  Instead of broth

  • Vegetable broth: The same amount. Lighter and slightly sweeter.
  • Chicken broth: The same amount. Richer and more savory; not vegetarian.
  • Bouillon cube, powder or paste + water: Follow the label for the amount of liquid. Close in flavor; a little saltier.

  All 4 swaps for broth

• 1 tbsp worcestershire sauce
  Swaps for worcestershire sauce

  Instead of Worcestershire sauce

  • Soy sauce + vinegar: 1 tbsp soy sauce + ¼ tsp vinegar + a pinch of sugar for each 1 tbsp. Savory and tangy, less complex.
  • Vegan Worcestershire: The same amount. Very close, with no anchovies.

  More for Worcestershire sauce

• 1 tsp dried thyme
  Swaps for dried thyme

  Instead of thyme

  • Fresh thyme: 1 tbsp chopped fresh for each 1 tsp dried (three times as much). Brighter and more lemony.
  • Italian seasoning or dried marjoram: The same amount. Close; Italian seasoning adds oregano and basil.

  More for thyme

• ¾ tsp kosher salt
  Swaps for kosher salt

  Instead of salt

  • Table salt or fine sea salt: About half as much as Diamond Crystal kosher, about ¾ as much as Morton kosher. The same saltiness when measured this way.
  • Salt by weight: 1 tsp is about 6 grams of table salt, 5 grams of Morton kosher, 3 grams of Diamond Crystal kosher. The most reliable way to swap, especially in baking and brines.

  More for salt

• ½ tsp black pepper
• 1 cup frozen peas and carrots
• ½ cup frozen corn ≈ 68 g

Different pan? Written for 9x13-inch rectangle; rescale the amounts for an 8x8, 9x13, round, loaf or sheet pan.

Cooking for a crowd? Pans, timing and salt for 12 to 50.

Missing something? Tap Swaps next to an ingredient, or see all substitutions.

Cook to 160°F inside (check with a thermometer).